Spooning with my significant other's sister - in front of my sister...
By ISpankMySO Story ID: 76
So for some context me and my significant other started dating our freshman year of University (we decided on the college we'd be attending together) because we had been bestfriends before then and I was scared to see her be with a guy that wasn't me, so I mustered up the courage to finally confess and officially be in a relationship with her a week before we left for school.
So her family was well aware of me and her being an item. Well anyway, during our freshman year after our fall semester I was spending the vacation at her parent's house with her family for the holidays. Now normally most parents would't approve of two eighteen- going on nineteen-year olds sharing a room/bed, but we had been bestfriends for all of highschool and when we weren't dating I would stay over and share the bed/bedroom because there was never worry of me doing something to their daughter (while yes, we were both in love with the other, neither of us admitted it to the other back then.)
So the first night we were there I was getting out of the shower late at night and was pretty drowsy so as soon as I was changed I immediately climbed into her bed. Her room is rather dark because her bed, pillows and comforters are darker colors so the only visible part of the bedroom was her tv because it was illuminating the rest of the room.
Now her sister's room on the other hand didn't have a TV so before I showered she was in there using it, but I'd assumed she'd left already and gone to bed. So once I'm in bed I notice my significant other (or at the time so I thought was my significant other) was sleeping so I decided to bring her in to my arms/body for some cuddling/spooning, because she likes being held while she sleeps.
So while half asleep I pull her in and get into the big spoon position while wrapping my arm around her waist and I give her a kiss on the neck and say goodnight (note her head was underneath a pillow and my eyes were half closed + it was dark so I couldn't really tell the difference between the two of them. Her sister was 17 at the time and an inch taller than my significant other so the difference to sleepy me is hardly noticeable.)
She doesn't say anything but I feel her back her butt up against my body so I assume she was barely awake and was telling me goodnight without saying actual words. So I close my eyes for what must have been less than thirty seconds when I hear my significant other scream as loud as she can "What the fuck is wrong with you you insensitive asshole?"
Ny significant other's sister jumped out of bed next to me. She turned on the light and I quickly come to my senses while me and her little sister explain the situation to her. Turns out my significant other had been in her sister's room waiting for her nails to dry and reading a book while her sister had fallen asleep in the bed watching TV, and she was going to wake her up so she could come sleep once I was done showering.
She laughs with us once she hears us out and we start to calmly get ready for bed, but not before her parents run in. So they ask what just happened and before my significant other and I can even open our mouths her little sister says while still blushing and very embarrassed "I just got caught in bed with my sister's significant other." Her parents start freaking out and her dad even threatens to kick me out and beat my ass. Before it escalates any further my significant other explains the situation and they forgive us, but force me to sleep in the guest room for the night.